{
  "title": "Google review sentiment: a paired text-field reanalysis",
  "version": "1.0.0",
  "date": "2026-11-07",
  "article": "https://reviewsboost.ca/google-review-sentiment-preprocessing-study.html",
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
  "creator": "ReviewsBoost Editorial Team",
  "source": {
    "creator": "Ioannis C. Drivas",
    "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18594870",
    "title": "Academic Libraries User Perception: A VADER-Enhanced Corpus of 7,605 Google Maps Reviews",
    "publication_date_declared": "2025-09-10",
    "repository_record_created": "2026-02-10",
    "version": "v1",
    "license": "CC BY 4.0",
    "workbook_url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/18594870/files/Academic%20Library%20User%20Perception%20A%20VADER-Enhanced%20Corpus%20of%207,605%20Google%20Maps%20Reviews.xlsx/content",
    "workbook_sha256": "62337cb2b304f7fbdbdd5ce646fa817eea3bb830ab37a872a29c1b45cde8bc8f",
    "workbook_md5": "07a6f254b04b1bb821cc3ec304067fb1",
    "collection_window_as_described": "March-July 2025",
    "geography_as_described": "Academic libraries worldwide; not a representative Canadian business sample"
  },
  "method": {
    "python": "3.12.0",
    "nltk": "3.9.4",
    "vader_module_sha256": "5dbf948203e62468e2e78d12f7273d04b8049455bd698503dfe286bcbc5afd03",
    "lexicon_url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nltk/nltk_data/gh-pages/packages/sentiment/vader_lexicon.zip",
    "lexicon_zip_sha256": "8adba4294eef3964d820bf655e37e61bdc3a341994356af59b74fb3b4a36ce5c",
    "lexicon_sha256": "0aabac74cd95def2dbedc04ce55e39698d91113ffadb6d86b87dd337c4d2184d",
    "text_fields": [
      "Google Translation",
      "Processed Text"
    ],
    "star_field": "review_rating (not the business aggregate rating field)",
    "classification": "positive >= +0.05; negative <= -0.05; neutral strictly between",
    "source_compound_field_used": false,
    "notes": [
      "No new translation, text cleaning, author identification or fake-review labelling.",
      "Each pair uses the same NLTK scorer/lexicon; only the stored input field changes.",
      "Threshold sensitivity reuses the same 7,015 records; no new independent observations.",
      "Library-balanced percentages average eligible within-library rates, not individual reviews.",
      "No removal decisions, customer results, Canada-wide prevalence or accuracy labels are observed."
    ]
  },
  "summary": {
    "reviews": 7015,
    "libraries": 86,
    "changed_labels": 1403,
    "changed_percent": 20.0,
    "direct_opposite_labels": 356,
    "direct_opposite_percent": 5.074839629365645,
    "unchanged_labels": 5612,
    "neutral_boundary_changes": 1047
  },
  "transitions": [
    {
      "english_label": "negative",
      "processed_label": "negative",
      "review_count": 394,
      "english_label_denominator": 737,
      "row_percent": 53.459973,
      "all_review_percent": 5.616536
    },
    {
      "english_label": "negative",
      "processed_label": "neutral",
      "review_count": 140,
      "english_label_denominator": 737,
      "row_percent": 18.995929,
      "all_review_percent": 1.995723
    },
    {
      "english_label": "negative",
      "processed_label": "positive",
      "review_count": 203,
      "english_label_denominator": 737,
      "row_percent": 27.544098,
      "all_review_percent": 2.893799
    },
    {
      "english_label": "neutral",
      "processed_label": "negative",
      "review_count": 18,
      "english_label_denominator": 829,
      "row_percent": 2.171291,
      "all_review_percent": 0.256593
    },
    {
      "english_label": "neutral",
      "processed_label": "neutral",
      "review_count": 759,
      "english_label_denominator": 829,
      "row_percent": 91.556092,
      "all_review_percent": 10.819672
    },
    {
      "english_label": "neutral",
      "processed_label": "positive",
      "review_count": 52,
      "english_label_denominator": 829,
      "row_percent": 6.272618,
      "all_review_percent": 0.741269
    },
    {
      "english_label": "positive",
      "processed_label": "negative",
      "review_count": 153,
      "english_label_denominator": 5449,
      "row_percent": 2.807855,
      "all_review_percent": 2.181041
    },
    {
      "english_label": "positive",
      "processed_label": "neutral",
      "review_count": 837,
      "english_label_denominator": 5449,
      "row_percent": 15.360617,
      "all_review_percent": 11.931575
    },
    {
      "english_label": "positive",
      "processed_label": "positive",
      "review_count": 4459,
      "english_label_denominator": 5449,
      "row_percent": 81.831529,
      "all_review_percent": 63.563792
    }
  ],
  "rating_strata": [
    {
      "stars": 1,
      "reviews": 536,
      "changed_labels": 184,
      "changed_percent": 34.328358,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 97,
      "english_negative": 326,
      "english_neutral": 60,
      "english_positive": 150,
      "processed_negative": 236,
      "processed_neutral": 125,
      "processed_positive": 175
    },
    {
      "stars": 2,
      "reviews": 231,
      "changed_labels": 79,
      "changed_percent": 34.199134,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 49,
      "english_negative": 105,
      "english_neutral": 36,
      "english_positive": 90,
      "processed_negative": 62,
      "processed_neutral": 50,
      "processed_positive": 119
    },
    {
      "stars": 3,
      "reviews": 353,
      "changed_labels": 96,
      "changed_percent": 27.195467,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 47,
      "english_negative": 104,
      "english_neutral": 62,
      "english_positive": 187,
      "processed_negative": 58,
      "processed_neutral": 103,
      "processed_positive": 192
    },
    {
      "stars": 4,
      "reviews": 937,
      "changed_labels": 178,
      "changed_percent": 18.996798,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 56,
      "english_negative": 97,
      "english_neutral": 109,
      "english_positive": 731,
      "processed_negative": 65,
      "processed_neutral": 221,
      "processed_positive": 651
    },
    {
      "stars": 5,
      "reviews": 4958,
      "changed_labels": 866,
      "changed_percent": 17.46672,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 107,
      "english_negative": 105,
      "english_neutral": 562,
      "english_positive": 4291,
      "processed_negative": 144,
      "processed_neutral": 1237,
      "processed_positive": 3577
    }
  ],
  "threshold_sensitivity": [
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.01,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1376,
      "changed_percent": 19.61511,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 406,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 5.787598
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.02,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1378,
      "changed_percent": 19.643621,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 402,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 5.730577
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.03,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1402,
      "changed_percent": 19.985745,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 368,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 5.245902
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.04,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1403,
      "changed_percent": 20.0,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 364,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 5.188881
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.05,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1403,
      "changed_percent": 20.0,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 356,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 5.07484
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.06,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1417,
      "changed_percent": 20.199572,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 335,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 4.775481
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.07,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1421,
      "changed_percent": 20.256593,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 332,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 4.732716
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.08,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1454,
      "changed_percent": 20.727014,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 310,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 4.419102
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.09,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1457,
      "changed_percent": 20.769779,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 306,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 4.362081
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.1,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1457,
      "changed_percent": 20.769779,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 302,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 4.305061
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.11,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1473,
      "changed_percent": 20.997862,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 283,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 4.034212
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.12,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1485,
      "changed_percent": 21.168924,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 274,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.905916
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.13,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1493,
      "changed_percent": 21.282965,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 260,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.706344
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.14,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1492,
      "changed_percent": 21.26871,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 258,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.677833
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.15,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1496,
      "changed_percent": 21.325731,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 256,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.649323
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.16,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1508,
      "changed_percent": 21.496793,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 237,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.378475
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.17,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1514,
      "changed_percent": 21.582324,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 233,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.321454
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.18,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1523,
      "changed_percent": 21.71062,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 223,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.178902
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.19,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1525,
      "changed_percent": 21.73913,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 221,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.150392
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.2,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1524,
      "changed_percent": 21.724875,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 218,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 3.107627
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.21,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1520,
      "changed_percent": 21.667855,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 206,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.936565
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.22,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1524,
      "changed_percent": 21.724875,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 202,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.879544
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.23,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1592,
      "changed_percent": 22.694227,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 180,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.56593
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.24,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1598,
      "changed_percent": 22.779758,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 176,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.508909
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.25,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1597,
      "changed_percent": 22.765502,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 173,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.466144
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.26,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1603,
      "changed_percent": 22.851033,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 163,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.323592
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.27,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1603,
      "changed_percent": 22.851033,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 158,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.252316
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.28,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1600,
      "changed_percent": 22.808268,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 149,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.12402
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.29,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1598,
      "changed_percent": 22.779758,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 149,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 2.12402
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.3,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1591,
      "changed_percent": 22.679971,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 132,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.881682
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.31,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1590,
      "changed_percent": 22.665716,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 125,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.781896
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.32,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1623,
      "changed_percent": 23.136137,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 116,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.653599
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.33,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1621,
      "changed_percent": 23.107627,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 113,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.610834
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.34,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1617,
      "changed_percent": 23.050606,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 110,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.568068
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.35,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1623,
      "changed_percent": 23.136137,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 103,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.468282
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.36,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1610,
      "changed_percent": 22.95082,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 102,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.454027
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.37,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1705,
      "changed_percent": 24.305061,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 91,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.29722
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.38,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1713,
      "changed_percent": 24.419102,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 89,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.26871
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.39,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1692,
      "changed_percent": 24.119743,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 82,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.168924
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.4,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1685,
      "changed_percent": 24.019957,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 79,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 1.126158
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.41,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1788,
      "changed_percent": 25.488239,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 69,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.983607
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.42,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1778,
      "changed_percent": 25.345688,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 65,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.926586
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.43,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1858,
      "changed_percent": 26.486101,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 61,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.869565
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.44,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1849,
      "changed_percent": 26.357805,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 61,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.869565
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.45,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1978,
      "changed_percent": 28.196721,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 55,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.784034
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.46,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1987,
      "changed_percent": 28.325018,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 53,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.755524
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.47,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1984,
      "changed_percent": 28.282252,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 53,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.755524
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.48,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1910,
      "changed_percent": 27.22737,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 46,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.655738
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.49,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1912,
      "changed_percent": 27.25588,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 44,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.627227
    },
    {
      "absolute_cutoff": 0.5,
      "reviews": 7015,
      "changed_labels": 1854,
      "changed_percent": 26.429081,
      "direct_opposite_labels": 41,
      "direct_opposite_percent": 0.584462
    }
  ],
  "library_weights": [
    {
      "scope": "all",
      "reviews": 7015,
      "eligible_libraries": 86,
      "changed_labels": 1403,
      "review_weighted_percent": 20.0,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 18.212939,
      "library_median_percent": 18.181818
    },
    {
      "scope": "1_star",
      "reviews": 536,
      "eligible_libraries": 71,
      "changed_labels": 184,
      "review_weighted_percent": 34.328358,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 34.200955,
      "library_median_percent": 26.315789
    },
    {
      "scope": "2_star",
      "reviews": 231,
      "eligible_libraries": 52,
      "changed_labels": 79,
      "review_weighted_percent": 34.199134,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 31.051437,
      "library_median_percent": 20.0
    },
    {
      "scope": "3_star",
      "reviews": 353,
      "eligible_libraries": 62,
      "changed_labels": 96,
      "review_weighted_percent": 27.195467,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 21.145742,
      "library_median_percent": 10.10101
    },
    {
      "scope": "4_star",
      "reviews": 937,
      "eligible_libraries": 77,
      "changed_labels": 178,
      "review_weighted_percent": 18.996798,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 18.605072,
      "library_median_percent": 15.384615
    },
    {
      "scope": "5_star",
      "reviews": 4958,
      "eligible_libraries": 85,
      "changed_labels": 866,
      "review_weighted_percent": 17.46672,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 15.616551,
      "library_median_percent": 15.384615
    },
    {
      "scope": "1_2_stars",
      "reviews": 767,
      "eligible_libraries": 75,
      "changed_labels": 263,
      "review_weighted_percent": 34.289439,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 32.587919,
      "library_median_percent": 30.0
    },
    {
      "scope": "4_5_stars",
      "reviews": 5895,
      "eligible_libraries": 86,
      "changed_labels": 1044,
      "review_weighted_percent": 17.709924,
      "equal_library_mean_percent": 15.894098,
      "library_median_percent": 15.384615
    }
  ],
  "data_audit": [
    {
      "metric": "source_title_count",
      "value": 7605,
      "unit": "title-declared reviews",
      "definition": "Repository title; not used as the observed denominator."
    },
    {
      "metric": "worksheet_rows_after_header",
      "value": 7056,
      "unit": "worksheet rows",
      "definition": "All XML row elements after the header, including score-only rows."
    },
    {
      "metric": "score_only_rows_excluded",
      "value": 41,
      "unit": "worksheet rows",
      "definition": "No review/business ID or review star rating; only the sentiment field is populated."
    },
    {
      "metric": "paired_review_records",
      "value": 7015,
      "unit": "reviews",
      "definition": "Unique business/review keys with integer 1-5 stars and both non-empty text fields."
    },
    {
      "metric": "title_minus_paired_records",
      "value": 590,
      "unit": "records difference",
      "definition": "Unreconciled title/sample gap; not labelled as removed or fake reviews."
    },
    {
      "metric": "distinct_libraries",
      "value": 86,
      "unit": "library profiles",
      "definition": "Distinct source google_id values; no institution or reviewer identifiers exported."
    },
    {
      "metric": "model_evaluations",
      "value": 14030,
      "unit": "deterministic model evaluations",
      "definition": "Two stored text representations per eligible review; not twice as many reviews."
    },
    {
      "metric": "first_review_year",
      "value": 2008,
      "unit": "source year",
      "definition": "From the source Year column."
    },
    {
      "metric": "last_review_year",
      "value": 2025,
      "unit": "source year",
      "definition": "From the source Year column."
    },
    {
      "metric": "smallest_library_sample",
      "value": 1,
      "unit": "review records",
      "definition": "Smallest eligible source library group."
    },
    {
      "metric": "largest_library_sample",
      "value": 1103,
      "unit": "review records",
      "definition": "Largest eligible source library group."
    }
  ],
  "distributions": [
    {
      "file": "google-sentiment-polarity-transitions.csv",
      "rows": 9,
      "sha256": "8aa3dfa3773afb33929f2df41c2e42f54dac35e38b83fb78a5bd787d76f7a4e7"
    },
    {
      "file": "google-sentiment-rating-strata.csv",
      "rows": 5,
      "sha256": "e00a2021cec6b5a9e71720225e66c3a7ea551db926393465c00c7365f98c6708"
    },
    {
      "file": "google-sentiment-threshold-sensitivity.csv",
      "rows": 50,
      "sha256": "e6050f653a48d10d1ad297c5867d99288ac98db0e33d14988afaf966e425fe1d"
    },
    {
      "file": "google-sentiment-library-weights.csv",
      "rows": 8,
      "sha256": "f7607d041705a6cdaeb5a9e781a9530b9329b8bd9e0da8aa1b50b2f5ac15ade5"
    },
    {
      "file": "google-sentiment-data-audit.csv",
      "rows": 11,
      "sha256": "9de28c7f0dbc406acb21f938ca823e20525fcb11244ddef47ef677bfa5393c63"
    }
  ]
}
